How Econometric Analysis Solved a Client’s Valuation Challenge in BGC

In today’s volatile property market, even fully leased buildings can face uncertainty when interest rates rise and yields compress. One of our clients is a developer with a 30-storey, 76-unit office tower in Bonifacio Global City. They sought clarity on whether their investment was still performing as expected. Through econometric analysis, we transformed complex market data into actions. This gave them financial insight that helped them see beyond occupancy rates. They focus on true value, risk, and return.

The Client’s Challenge

A private developer approached our team with a critical question:

“Is our 30-storey, 76-unit office building in Bonifacio Global City still financially viable under current market conditions?”

The client had completed construction two years earlier. The building was fully leased. They were concerned about rising interest rates. Modest rental escalations are eroding investment returns.

The property’s leasing structure appeared competitive. It includes a mix of bare-shell and fitted office units. These units range from PhP1,500 to PhP1,800 per sqm per month. However, management wanted to know if the building’s cash flows truly reflected its economic value. They questioned whether adjustments in pricing, escalation, or capital structure were necessary.

In short, the challenge was not occupancy — it was understanding profitability in a tightening capital market.

Our Approach

Instead of relying on conventional yield assumptions, our team applied econometric modeling. This is an analytical framework that links property-level performance to measurable macroeconomic drivers.

We began by reconstructing the building’s income statement. We also reconstructed rental schedules across 76 office units and all 30 floors. We factored in current lease terms and 3% annual escalations. Additionally, we used observed market data from Pinnacle Real Estate Consulting and Arcadis Philippines.

From there, we derived two distinct discount rates using both finance-based and property-specific risk models:

MethodFormulaResult
Finance-Based (CAPM)R=Rf+β(ERP)+SRP17.40%
Real Estate Build-UpR=Rf+∑RiskPremiums13.16%

Each parameter was anchored to empirical data. This includes the risk-free rate, beta, and risk premiums. These were tied to data from the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas, PSA inflation series, and Damodaran’s country risk tables.

By integrating these variables, we aligned the building’s valuation with economic reality rather than static, one-size-fits-all assumptions.

Findings: Translating Data into Decision

Our projection model covered a 10-year period, reflecting the economic life of the building’s interior improvements.

Discount RatePresent Value of Cash Flows (PhP)Fit-out & Equipment Cost (PhP)NPV (PhP)Interpretation
13.16%11,801,35812,472,358–671,000Breakeven (stabilized scenario)
17.40%10,655,64612,472,358–1,816,000Slightly negative (equity scenario)

Despite the modest NPV results, the cash inflows were sufficient to recover the capital outlay within the project’s economic life. This indicated a financially balanced asset — not speculative, but self-sustaining and capital-preserving.

The key insight for the client was that profitability was not being lost. It was simply redefined by changing macroeconomic conditions. In other words, the property’s yield had adjusted to reflect a maturing market.

We extended the analysis to examine how the project would perform under various economic shocks:

  • A 1% increase in the discount rate (e.g., due to rising interest rates) would reduce the property’s value by approximately PhP700,000.
  • A 1% increase in rental escalation would improve valuation by about PhP500,000.

This confirmed that interest-rate and capital-market movements have a greater effect on value than marginal rental adjustments.

The adopted PhP1,800 per sqm rate for fitted offices is advantageous. It places the property squarely within the prime BGC rental range of PhP1,400–PhP1,900. The effective yield is 7–8% per annum. This is a level consistent with institutional benchmarks in Metro Manila’s investment-grade office sector.

The results of the econometric analysis allowed the client to make well-informed and financially sound decisions. Our findings confirmed the current rental rate structure of PHP 1,500 to PHP 1,800 per square meter per month. This rate was aligned with prevailing market conditions. These rates match the conditions in Bonifacio Global City. Attempting to increase the rates further would risk higher tenant turnover without producing a proportional increase in building value. Hence, the most strategic course was to maintain existing rents, ensuring consistent occupancy and stable revenue streams.

Second, the study validated the client’s 3% annual escalation policy. It demonstrated that this policy accurately reflected the average inflation rate. It also matched the standard lease renewal adjustments in the area. This approach ensured that income growth would remain sustainable and competitive, balancing tenant affordability with long-term asset performance.

Finally, we advised the client to reclassify the building’s investment profile—from a short-term growth-driven asset to a core income property. This repositioning recognized that the building had already reached stabilization, with 100% occupancy and predictable cash inflows. The property could now serve as a capital preservation anchor within the client’s portfolio. It would provide reliable income to offset higher-risk, higher-yield developments elsewhere.

What initially seemed like a modest or even negative Net Present Value (NPV) was reinterpreted. It became a measure of financial efficiency. The building’s inflows matched its cost of capital. This indicated that it was performing exactly as expected in a mature market like BGC. Through this shift in perspective, the client gained a clearer understanding of the property’s value. The client also gained a more strategic framework for portfolio management, anchored in data, discipline, and economic logic.

This case highlights how econometric reasoning transforms real estate valuation from a static appraisal into a dynamic decision-making tool. We treated rents, yields, and escalation rates as variables linked to broader economic conditions. This approach helped us uncover not just the property’s value but also the logic behind it. The client learned that a neutral or breakeven NPV is not necessarily a weakness. It can signify equilibrium and maturity in a market. In this market, stability is the new form of strength.

For investors, the key takeaway is that macro-driven valuation brings clarity in times of uncertainty. Understanding how discount rates move with monetary policy provides a sharper sense of timing. Recognizing how escalation aligns with inflation sharpens your understanding of risk and opportunity. For developers, the lesson is strategic. Once a building reaches full occupancy and stable returns, it should be viewed as a core income asset. This asset anchors the portfolio and preserves capital rather than being seen as a speculative venture.

Ultimately, the study demonstrates that data and discipline lead to confidence. In Bonifacio Global City, every percentage point of yield and risk can mean millions in value. Econometric analysis offers a distinct advantage. It gives clients the ability to move beyond intuition. Consultants can also ground their investment strategies on measurable, defensible evidence.

By: Gus Agosto, JD, REA, REB, REC, MA Economics (University of San Carlos)
Paralegal – Real Estate, Environmental & Corporate Law

AA+ Appraisal  Celebrates 13 Years of Trusted Real Estate Practice

Cebu City, Philippines – August 2, 2025


Today marks the 13th anniversary of AA+ Appraisal  & Consulting (formerly AA RealtyPro Solutions), a Philippine-based valuation and consulting firm recognized for its commitment to credible, objectivity, and professional integrity. Since its establishment on August 2, 2012, the firm has delivered defensible valuation reports across sectors—supporting legal proceedings, institutional clients, and high-stakes transactions with diligence and impartiality.

From Modest Beginnings to National Footprint

AA RealtyPro Solutions was founded by Augusto B. Agosto, a licensed real estate appraiser, consultant, and educator. Following his licensure by the Professional Regulation Commission (PRC), Mr. Agosto served in leadership roles in national appraisal firms before establishing AA RealtyPro. What began as a general real estate service evolved into a focused valuation practice grounded in standards, documentation, and ethical conduct.

In 2014, the firm formally entered the valuation profession. Among its earliest corporate clients were General Milling Corporation and Classical Geometry Export Corporation. Its track record expanded when Cebu CFI Community Cooperative, one of the largest cooperatives in the region, appointed the firm to appraise its extensive property holdings—a defining milestone in AA RealtyPro’s institutional credibility.

Valuation for the Courts and the Public Interest

AA RealtyPro Solutions is widely regarded for its expertise in litigation-related valuation. In November 2014, Mr. Agosto was appointed Appraisal Commissioner by the Regional Trial Court of Lapu-Lapu City, marking the firm’s entry into judicially recognized appraisal work. Since then, it has prepared court-admissible valuation reports in cases involving:

  • Just compensation and expropriation
  • Property partition and estate settlement
  • Reconstitution, annulment, and boundary disputes
  • Housing development

The firm’s reports follow the Rules of Court, comply with RESA (RA 9646), and meet standards of independence, clarity, and verifiability—core principles of credible appraisal practice. Its work has aided both courts and counsels in resolving technically and legally complex property disputes.

Educating Professionals and Upholding Ethical Standards

Mr. Agosto serves as a faculty member in real estate and tax law at Trinity University, Philippine Christian University, Gardner College, Lyceum of Alabang, Cronasia College and the University of San Carlos and leads professional development programs on document analysis, adjustment methodology, and valuation reporting. Through lectures, bootcamps, and public speaking engagements, he has helped shape a generation of real estate professionals to value not just property—but truth, responsibility, and evidence-based judgment.

He is also the founding president of the Society of Litigation Valuation Experts (SOLVE), a body committed to raising ethical and technical standards in valuation. In 2024, he contributed to the Implementing Rules and Regulations (IRR) of the Real Property Valuation and Reassessment Act (RPVRA), with a focus on litigation standards, revaluation intervals, and LGU-based valuation systems.

Expanding Nationally, Maintaining Credibility

Since 2017, AA RealtyPro has expanded its service coverage from Cebu and the Visayas to Metro Manila and Northern Luzon, undertaking assignments for:

·  Commercial buildings and condominiums in NCR

·  Institutional properties including schools and universities

·  Industrial assets including warehouses with equipment and machinery

·  Foreshore lands, easements, and properties with encumbrances

  • Consulting works for multilateral agencies and international institutions

Its valuation portfolio spans residential, commercial, industrial, and special-use properties, serving a diverse clientele nationwide. Beyond appraisal, the firm is also engaged in real estate consulting, feasibility analysis, and property-related studies that inform investment, development, and legal decisions. These services are delivered with meticulous documentation, well-grounded assumptions, and defensible analysis—ensuring that each report upholds the highest standards of technical accuracy and professional credibility.

In select engagements, AA Appraisal integrates environmental and locational research, particularly in land use-sensitive and resource-regulated properties, further enhancing the reliability and contextual relevance of its advisory work.

Trusted. Impartial. Defensible.

AA RealtyPro Solutions maintains a clear ethical position on conflict of interest and professional boundaries. The firm avoids dual roles in brokerage and appraisal, ensures the confidentiality of client data, and practices valuation strictly in accordance with the International Valuation Standards (IVS).

Its founder continues to engage in both local and international training, including the Complex Properties Valuation Program in Thailand and speaking roles at the FIABCI Asia-Pacific Convention and the upcoming Resort Valuation Forum in Pattaya.

 Moving Forward: A Commitment to Truth and Credible Insights

As AA RealtyPro marks its 13th year, it reaffirms its core mission:

“To deliver impartial, legally compliant, and analytically sound valuation and consulting services that support public trust, judicial clarity, and institutional transparency.”

With every appraisal assignment, the firm aims not only to determine property value—but to uphold professional truth in service of the public, the courts, and the profession.

Gratitude and Acknowledgment

To all clients, counsels, institutions, and colleagues who have placed their trust in AA RealtyPro Solutions—thank you. Your confidence inspires our continued pursuit of credibility, clarity, and contribution.

AA RealtyPro Solutions
Established August 2, 2012
“Trusted Insights. Defensible Reports. Ethical Practice.”

Why Title Annotations and Encumbrances Matter in Property Appraisal

In valuation, the fine print on the title can be as valuable—or as dangerous—as the land itself.

In real estate appraisal, numbers alone do not tell the whole story. A property’s legal status—particularly the annotations and encumbrances appearing on its title or tax declaration—can drastically alter its worth. While some may view these legal markings as mere notarial footnotes, a seasoned property appraiser understands that such entries are crucial to determining the property’s true value, marketability, and risk profile.  One of the most important but sometimes overlooked aspects of valuation is the presence of annotations and encumbrances on the property’s Transfer Certificate of Title (TCT), Original Certificate of Title (OCT), or Tax Declaration. These annotations—whether involving tax delinquency, pending litigation, or other restrictions—can drastically alter a property’s value, marketability, and highest and best use (HBU). For the professional appraiser, understanding and correctly interpreting these legal markings is essential, not optional.

Why Appraisers Must Pay Attention

There are several compelling reasons why a diligent appraiser must care about annotations and encumbrances.

First, these legal burdens directly affect market value—the core product of any appraisal. Buyers in the open market are generally unwilling to pay full price for a property encumbered by unresolved claims, legal disputes, or forfeiture risks. Appraisers must therefore consider how each annotation may cause potential buyers to either walk away or demand a discount.

Second, legal risk translates to value risk. Annotations such as a lis pendens, adverse claim, or a writ of attachment signal potential issues with ownership, possession, or future usability. Even if a property looks physically sound, a legal cloud on its title will make it less attractive and inherently riskier. Prudent appraisers account for this by adjusting their valuation assumptions, often applying a discount or issuing a qualified opinion.

Third, these annotations frequently affect the property’s highest and best use (HBU)—a foundational concept in valuation. If a property is subject to restrictive covenants, reversionary clauses, or foreshore lease limitations, its legal permissibility for development or other productive use may be severely constrained. The appraiser must therefore revise the HBU analysis and its associated value estimate accordingly.

Fourth, annotations impair a property’s marketability. For instance, a property that has been auctioned off for tax delinquency but is still within the redemption period cannot be sold with confidence. Similarly, if a property was inherited but the title transfer is not yet perfected, there may be co-heir disputes or administrative delays. In both cases, the property may be legally transferable only in theory, but not in practice—at least not without cost or time delays.

Fifth, annotations affect the property’s loanable value or equity value. Banks and other financial institutions are wary of lending against titles that carry risks. For example, a property mortgaged beyond its current market value or encumbered with a lien from unpaid taxes may only be eligible for partial financing, or worse, may be rejected altogether as loan collateral. This has direct implications for the appraiser’s task in estimating not just market value, but the net realizable or mortgageable value.

Finally, ignoring these factors may violate the appraiser’s professional and legal responsibilities. Under the Real Estate Service Act (RA 9646), the appraiser is required to exercise due diligence and report all material conditions that affect the value of the property. International Valuation Standards (IVS) and the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP) similarly require full disclosure and the proper interpretation of legal burdens. Failing to do so may expose the appraiser to liability, loss of license, or reputational damage.

Understanding the Specific Impact of Common Annotations

To make these risks and responsibilities more concrete, let’s examine how common annotations and encumbrances impact valuation:

A Notice of Tax Delinquency or Forfeiture carries a negative impact on value and significantly impairs marketability due to the risk of government seizure. When a Certificate of Sale appears on the title—typically following a tax auction—the buyer only has conditional ownership until the redemption period lapses. This also warrants a discounted valuation and caution in reporting.

A Lis Pendens indicates that the property is subject to ongoing litigation. Its presence severely impairs marketability and imposes legal uncertainty, which in turn reduces value. An Adverse Claim similarly signals a third-party interest in the property that contradicts the titleholder’s claim. While not always litigated, it still creates hesitation for buyers and lenders, pulling values downward.

A Levy or Writ of Attachment represents a judicial restriction. Courts attach the property to secure a possible judgment, and while the property is not yet seized, its transferability is legally curtailed. This justifies a risk adjustment in the valuation.

If the title carries a Foreshore Lease or a Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) annotation, it usually means that the property is within the public domain (such as coastal or reclaimed land). Ownership is limited to leasehold rights, not fee simple. This not only reduces the appraised value to the leasehold interest but also conditions its use based on government regulation.

An Affidavit of Loss or Reconstitution of title temporarily affects the property’s marketability, especially if the reconstitution process is incomplete. Although this may only have a neutral to slightly negative impact on value, it still warrants disclosure and may be included as a limiting condition in the report.

A Real Estate Mortgage (REM), if current and performing, generally has a neutral impact on market value, assuming the appraisal is for market purposes and not equity extraction. However, the appraiser must still distinguish between total market value and the equity portion when applicable.

An Easement or Servitude, such as a right of way or drainage restriction, slightly reduces the value and may condition the property’s utility. If the easement affects buildable area or accessibility, this becomes a material consideration.

Reversion clauses or restrictive covenants are more serious. These limit future development, prohibit certain uses, or allow the property to revert to a former owner under certain conditions. As these significantly constrain HBU and market flexibility, they usually result in a negative value adjustment.

Lastly, annotations involving Deeds of Donation, Inheritance, or Partition may suggest that the property was recently transferred or is part of a co-ownership arrangement. If the legal transfer is incomplete or the estate is unsettled, the title remains in flux. This affects both value and marketability, particularly if there is a risk of future claims or if the sale requires consent from multiple parties.

In real estate valuation, legal clarity is just as important as physical condition. Title annotations and encumbrances represent real risks, limitations, and burdens that influence the value of a property. Whether through discounted sales, delayed transactions, restricted use, or diminished loanability, these legal notations affect how market participants perceive and engage with real estate assets.

The professional appraiser must go beyond mere physical inspection and apply legal awareness, risk sensitivity, and valuation expertise to provide credible, well-supported opinions of value. Every annotation tells a story—of ownership, encumbrance, or uncertainty—and the appraiser must read, interpret, and reflect that story in the appraisal report.

AA Consultants Expands Reach with Strategic Housing and Infras Development Engagements

AA+ Appraisal & Consultancy proudly announces the completion of its real estate consulting in Dipolog City and Batangas. The consultancy firm has been commissioned to conduct comprehensive studies on projects in Cebu, Dipolog City, Bohol, Leyte, Lapulapu City, and Batangas, demonstrating a proactive approach to addressing various challenges within the real estate sector.

A significant milestone for AA Consultants is their recent engagement as development consultants for an expansive housing project covering Dipolog City, Zamboanga del Norte. This upcoming 2.8-hectare development is strategically positioned to evolve into a vital subdivision, serving both urban and provincial populations due to its proximity to the city center. The consultancy firm has diligently undertaken feasibility and economic viability studies, laying the groundwork for a successful venture.

Recall that AA+ Appraisal & Consultancy was hired by the Japan International Cooperation Agency through its local counterpart to provide consulting services for the 19.8-kilometer Marawi City Ring Road -SP7. This project, which connects several towns in the province of Lanao del Sur, focuses primarily on residential and agricultural areas along the Marawi City Ring Road (SP7).

Gus Agosto, President, and Chief Executive Officer of AA+ Appraisal & Consultancy, expressed his enthusiasm about this new endeavor, stating, “We are truly excited to add yet another magnificent project to our portfolio of development consulting opportunities.”

Prior to this achievement, AA Consultants conducted a comprehensive feasibility study for a 50-hectare Agro-Industrial Farm in South Cebu, showcasing their commitment to diverse and impactful projects. Furthermore, the consultancy firm played a pivotal role in proposed subdivision developments in Batangas, Lapulapu City, Bohol, and Maasin, Southern Leyte, conducting highest and best-use studies and marketability studies to optimize the potential of these areas.

Beyond real estate, AA Consultants has extended its expertise to other crucial sectors, providing invaluable consultancy services for a water treatment facility delivering 20 million liters of water daily to the Metropolitan Cebu Water District. Additionally, the firm collaborated with the largest waste management company in Cebu, underscoring its commitment to contributing to sustainable and efficient solutions.

With these recent accomplishments, AA Consultants solidifies its position as a leading force in development consulting, showcasing versatility and excellence across various projects that positively impact communities and industries alike.

“AA+ Appraisal & Consultancy, along with its development consulting team, is driven by its purpose in nation-building, aiming to play a pivotal role in fostering sustainable development and progress across the country. AA+ Consultancy stands as a trusted and versatile partner, uniquely positioned to offer end-to-end solutions for a wide spectrum of development projects. Our development consulting work promotes sustainable, inclusive, and economically vibrant communities,” concluded Consultant Economist Agosto.